The Best S&P 500 Index Funds in 2025

Top S&P 500 index funds and ETFs in 2025 — expense ratios and minimums

FundProviderExpense RatioAccount TypeMin InvestmentType
FXAIXFidelity0.015%Any Fidelity account$0Mutual fund
FZROXFidelity0.000%Fidelity account only$0Zero-fee total market fund
VFIAXVanguard0.04%Vanguard account$3,000Mutual fund
VOOVanguard ETF0.03%Any brokerage$1 fractionalETF
IVViShares ETF0.03%Any brokerage$1 fractionalETF
SPYState Street ETF0.09%Any brokerage$1 fractionalETF
SWPPXSchwab0.02%Schwab account$0Mutual fund

How to Open an Account and Start Investing

  1. Open a Roth IRA at Fidelity (free, 10 minutes): best first account for most investors under $150,000 income
  2. Link your bank account using routing and account numbers
  3. Transfer an initial investment amount (minimum $0 at Fidelity and Schwab)
  4. Search for FXAIX (Fidelity S&P 500 index fund) within the account
  5. Place a purchase order for any dollar amount using fractional share investing
  6. Set up automatic monthly investments for your target contribution amount
  7. Enable dividend reinvestment to maximize compounding
📈$500/Month in S&P 500 for 30 Years

At the S&P 500 nominal historical return of 10%: $500/month for 30 years grows to $1,130,000. At a more conservative 7% reflecting current valuations: $612,000. At the real (after inflation) return of approximately 7% historical: $612,000 in nominal dollars, roughly $355,000 in today's purchasing power. Even the conservative projection shows more than $600,000 built from $180,000 in total contributions.

2025 S&P 500 Context: What to Expect

The S&P 500 enters 2025 with elevated valuations (P/E ratio approximately 22 to 25 versus historical average 15 to 16). The Shiller CAPE of 35 to 37 historically suggests 10-year forward returns of 4% to 7% versus the 10% long-run average. For the investment calculator: use 7% as a conservative base for a 20 to 30-year projection, not the 10% historical average. This accounts for the probability of mean reversion in valuations over the next decade.

S&P 500 vs. Total Market: Which Is Better?

The S&P 500 covers 500 large-cap U.S. stocks representing approximately 80% of U.S. market capitalization. The total market index covers all 4,000+ publicly traded U.S. companies, adding small and mid-cap exposure. Historically, small-cap stocks have provided a return premium over large-cap stocks (the small-cap factor), but this premium has been inconsistent in recent decades. For most investors, either S&P 500 or total market works well. The total market's broader diversification is a slight advantage at no additional cost.

VOO vs. SPY vs. IVV: Which ETF to Choose

S&P 500 ETF comparison: annual fee on $100,000 and when to choose each

ETFExpense RatioAnnual Fee on $100KDifference vs. SPYChoose If
VOO (Vanguard)0.03%$30/yrSave $60/yr vs SPYYou prefer Vanguard or want lowest cost ETF
IVV (iShares)0.03%$30/yrSave $60/yr vs SPYYou use a non-Vanguard brokerage
SPY (State Street)0.09%$90/yrBaselineNeed maximum liquidity for trading (not needed for buy-and-hold)
FXAIX (Fidelity)0.015%$15/yrSave $75/yr vs SPYYou use Fidelity; slight lowest-cost advantage

Project Your S&P 500 Investment Growth

Enter your contribution and use 7% to 10% to see the range of 30-year outcomes.

Open Investment Calculator →