Real Returns on Fixed-Income Investments at Various Inflation Rates
Real returns on fixed-income investments at various inflation scenarios
| Investment | Nominal Rate | At 2% Inflation | At 4% Inflation | At 7% Inflation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30-year Treasury bond | 4.5% | +2.45% real | +0.48% real | −2.34% real |
| 10-year Treasury | 4.25% | +2.21% real | +0.24% real | −2.57% real |
| 5-year CD | 4.50% | +2.45% real | +0.48% real | −2.34% real |
| Fixed annuity (5%) | 5.0% | +2.94% real | +0.96% real | −1.87% real |
| Money market (4.75%) | 4.75% | +2.70% real | +0.72% real | −2.10% real |
| TIPS (1.2% + CPI) | 1.2% + CPI adj. | +1.2% real | +1.2% real | +1.2% real |
Why 2022 Was Catastrophic for Bonds
Bond prices move inversely to interest rates. When the Fed raised rates from 0% to 4.5% in 2022, existing bonds with lower coupons became less valuable. The Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index fell 13% nominally in 2022. With 7%+ inflation, the real return for bonds in 2022 was approximately −20%. This was the worst year for bonds in modern U.S. history.
A fixed annuity paying $3,000/month seems secure. But at 3% inflation, that $3,000 buys 26% less in 10 years and 45% less in 20 years. A retiree on a fixed annuity with no COLA provision experiences a relentless real income decline. After 25 years, the fixed annuity payment has roughly half its original purchasing power.
Strategies to Protect Fixed-Income Portfolios from Inflation
- TIPS: principal adjusts with CPI; real return is guaranteed (currently ~1.5–2.0% real)
- Short-duration bonds: less price sensitivity to rate changes; reinvest at higher rates as they mature
- Floating-rate bonds: coupon adjusts with short-term rates; limited inflation protection but reduces rate risk
- Series I savings bonds: rate adjusts with CPI every 6 months; state-tax-exempt, but limited to $10,000/yr
- TIPS ladder: purchase TIPS maturing at future dates corresponding to income needs
Calculate the Real Return on Any Fixed-Income Investment
Enter the nominal rate and inflation assumption to find the real purchasing power return.